Found 26 August 1866, Slains Castle, Cruden Bay, Aberdeenshire.
In a bottle:
Ship City of New York. Sailed 6th December with a cargo of cotton, bound for Granton. Went out of her course 13th Jan. Boats all lost. Ship going down. God have mercy on our souls. — GEORGE ADAMS, carpenter.
Picked up by a gardener at the 16th century Slains Castle, more than a hundred miles north of the City of New York’s stated destination of Granton, Edinburgh. An Inman passenger liner also named City of New York was reported safe.
[Shields Daily Gazette, 1 September 1866]